|
Grading the Outgames
By
Cyd Zeigler jr.
Participants:
How do you rate the Outgames?
Photo Galleries:
Over
550 pics from water polo, tennis, swimming, opening ceremonies and
more!
What an incredible
week in Montreal, and what an incredible event GLISA and Montreal
2006 put on. It was telling that in the final days of the Outgames,
I found it difficult to find someone who had harsh criticism for the
event, and no one who would grade it worse than a B, with most
giving A's. Here's my final assessment:
REGISTRATION: A
Everything seemed to flow beautifully. The
volunteers registering were nice and helpful; the space was very
large and made it easy to move around; the process was quick and
painless. I tried to add a sport to my registration to see how it
would go; the line was a little long, but the process was rather
easy.
SPONSORSHIPS/FINANCES: A
Just like the Gay Games in Chicago, it
looks like these Outgames will come in on-budget or darn close.
OPENING
CEREMONIES: A-
I haven't gotten emotional at either of my
Gay Games opening ceremonies, but this one got to me. I marched in
with the athletes, and when we entered Olympic Stadium, the sound
and the spectacle was overwhelming. I think a part of that is the
fact that it was in a dome; that makes a big difference. It was 25
minutes of speeches, which I still think was a bit too long (by five
to 10 minutes). And I was really put off by the Montreal crowd who
booed one of the speakers. But, it was a fun show and seemed
well-received.
GEOGRAPHIC
REPRESENTATION: A-
What was cool about this was that the
conference the week before the Outgames started fed people from so
many different countries into the event. I met participants from six
continents, which was cool. If the American representation had been
stronger, this grade would have been higher.
MY ADOPTED
SPORT, TENNIS: A-
While I didn't play any sports, it was
tennis that I went to five straight days to see a friend march to
the semifinals. I did hear someone complain about a scheduling
snafu; but, otherwise, I heard strong praise for the organization of
the tennis tournament. It came across to me as a very professional
tournament. My minor criticism: The seedings were way off. The top
seed in the B-division lost his first match, 6-0, 6-0, to someone
who lost his next match, 6-1, 6-1.
VENUES: A-
It's hard to imagine the venues could get
much better, though handball was in a gym worse than the one in my
former elementary school. I also loved how many of the sports were
organized around mini villages; the one at Claude Robillard was
exceptional.
CITY
PRESENCE: A+
The presence of the Outgames was
everywhere from, literally, the moment I stepped into the airport.
And where there weren't posters promoting the Outgames or the
opening ceremonies, there were volunteers or signs pointing you in
the right direction. St. Catherine Street was blocked off (in part
because of Gay Pride) which built the presence in the city. It's
hard to imagine it being any better.
MEDIA
EXPOSURE: B
This is a hard grade to give. The exposure
in Montreal was phenomenal, with daily presence in the newspapers
and on the TV, and certainly some radio presence. The American press
didn't report on it much, which was to be expected.
RESULTS
REPORTING: B+
As with Chicago, a big improvement, thanks
to the Internet, over past Gay Games. Some results were still slow
to come in, but organizers seem to be getting most everything onto
their Web site.
BEYOND THE SPORTS: A+
Incredible. What the organizers did
outside the sports blew away anything I had seen before. Viger
Square, which was essentially the athletes village for the week, was
an incredible space (though it was undermined three or four evenings
by rain). St. Catherine Street was shut down, which created a
mile-long block party in the Village. There were parties for each
sport, other parties to celebrate the Outgames as a whole. And the
pool party was quite fun.
OTHER: B
The weather, for the most part, was as
good as you could hope for in the first week of August. One day was
partially marred by rain, and another was scorching hot. But, the
other six days were sunny and warm. There seemed to be a volunteer
on every street corner, but they sometimes couldn't answer basic
questions.
OVERALL:
A-
The production of these Outgames will be
the standard by which all future events like this are measured.
There were some hiccups, as there will be in any event. But, from
organization to the City of Montreal itself to the people with whom
I worked while reporting on the Outgames, the event itself was a
smashing success.
Back to Outgames 2006 Index
|