Visit the Outsports Store
Sport Sections
Baseball
Basketball
NFL  College F'ball
Gay Games
Olympics
Softball
Tennis
Women's Sports
More
Interact
Clubhouse
Polls
Local Sections
View Member Profiles
Local Events
Local News
Local Teams & Leagues
Features
Community Outreach
Featured Articles
From The Wire
Making A Difference
Out Athletes
Out on Campus
Regular Columnists
Week In Review
Tops & Bottoms
For the Eyes
Locker Rooms
Picture This
Other Sections
About Outsports
Entertainment
Gay Sports News
Olympics
Outsports in the Media
E-mail Outsports.com

Tuaolo Voted 2002 Top Story

By Jim Buzinski
Outsports.com


The coming out of Esera Tuaolo, who became only the third NFL player to ever declare his homosexuality, was voted the top gay sports story of 2002 by readers of Outsports.com.

Tuaolo came out in late October on HBO’s “Real Sports” and immediately became the subject of widespread media attention. Tuaolo’s story resonated with many; having a 300-pound, tough defensive lineman come out as gay went a long way in destroying stereotypes.

Tuaolo, 34, played in the NFL for nine years, most of them with the Minnesota Vikings. He retired in 1999 and lives with his partner, Mitchell Wherley, and their two adopted children. He is pursuing an acting and singing career. "I'm just your typical gay Samoan ex-nose tackle who would like to break into show business," Tuaolo joked to one interviewer.

Readers who voted for Tuaolo stressed the positive aspects of having an ex-jock come out as gay. He joins David Kopay and Roy Simmons as the only NFL players who have publicly come out.

“I voted for Esera because I think that in such a physical sport such as football, it more than woke up people who have long associated feminine qualities with homosexual men,” wrote one reader.

Tuaolo’s story was voted No. 1 by 60% in an Outsports online poll. The speculation surrounding Mike Piazza’s sexuality was second with 20%. Gay Games VI in Sydney was third with 12%. Antigay comments by NFL players Jeremy Shockey and Garrison Hearst received 4%, the same as the declaration by WNBA player Sue Wicks that she is a lesbian.

Robert Lipsyte, columnist for the New York Times, picked Tuaolo as his Sportsman of the Year. “His courage in a homophobic Sports World befits what we have been conditioned to believe about football players. Too often we've been disappointed, not the least by several of Tuaolo's teammates who were concerned that showering with a known gay man would cause people to question their masculinity,” Lipsyte wrote in his Dec. 29 column.

After Tuaolo came out, the spotlight turned to how NFL players would deal with a gay teammate. The reactions varied widely. Many players refused to comment, which indicated a discomfort to even address the issue. Some were enlightened, such as Byron Chamberlain, a former teammate of Tuaolo, who said: "We as a culture have to be open-minded to different things and different situations, and that goes for sexuality, religion and different cultures. Because you come in a locker room like this, there are people who are totally different from me, probably grew up in a totally different environment from me. But it just comes down to being open-minded and being understanding of other people."

Chamberlain’s open-mindedness was countered by the likes of Garrison Hearst, a San Francisco 49ers running back, who told the Fresno Bee: “Aww, hell no! I don't want any faggots on my team. I know this might not be what people want to hear, but that's a punk. I don't want any faggots in this locker room." In a sign that overt homophobia is no longer acceptable, Hearst was forced to publicly apologize and the team issued statements deploring what the player said.

The Tuaolo story had legs, continuing to be a subject on TV and in print well into December. His visibility has raised the consciousness, if not the tolerance, of the public about gays in professional sports. His impact was perhaps best summed up by Randi Reitan, a Minneapolis-area resident, who wrote a letter to the Minneapolis Star-Tribune praising a feature story on Tuaolo and his family:

“It was a gift to every family struggling for gay rights. It was a gift to everyone who read it, for it opened the door to understanding.

“We have a gay son. We appreciate so much when the news shares personal stories like this one.

“It is an act of courage for Esera Tuaolo and Mitchell Wherley to open their lives up for this lesson in love and acceptance. It is through stories like theirs that walls of misunderstanding are broken down.”

Dec. 30, 2002


  TOP STORY NOMINEES
 

Esera Tuaolo Comes Out

Tuaolo became only the third former NFL player to come out as gay. His announcement on HBO in October sparked a flurry of coverage of the issue of gays in sports. Tuaolo, his partner and their two kids make for an appealing family and his story resonated with many. Having a 300-pound and tough defensive lineman come out as gay went a long way in destroying stereotypes. Read more

Gay Games VI Are Held

The Games have become an institution in the gay and lesbian community and this year’s event in Sydney was considered a success. The organization was chaotic and the event was a big money-loser, but 99% of participants and attendees could have cared less. The weather was perfect, the city was welcoming and beguiling and the competition was first-rate. And who could resist those sexy Aussie accents? Read more

Mike Piazza Comes Out … As Straight

Mike Piazza’s comments that he is a heterosexual, in response to a blind item in a New York Post gossip column in May, may have done more to raise the issue of gays in sports than any other. The media coverage was unprecedented and it got fans talking openly about their favorite jocks being gay. 

Jeremy Shockey and Garrison Hearst: Anti-Gay Twins

Homophobic comments by Shockey, a New York Giants tight end, and Hearst, a San Francisco 49ers running back, brought the issue of gays and sports to America’s favorite sport—pro football. Shockey was so off-base that he offended Howard Stern, while Hearst was forced to apologize for saying “I don't want any faggots on my team.” 

Sue Wicks Comes Out

Wicks is a rare bird—an openly gay active player. The New York Liberty basketball star was matter-of-fact in stating this year she is a lesbian. "I'm not ashamed of who I am, but I don't think it has anything to do with basketball," Wicks told Sports Illustrated. "You're a wife, a mother, a lesbian, who cares? The real victory will come when people just view us as athletes." 

When asked how many straight players there were in the WNBA, Wicks told the Village Voice in 2000: “I can't say how many, but it would be easier to count the straight ones." We’re still waiting for others to publicly join Wicks. Read more