QUOTE
RazorbackTX
With all due respect...
Was this a comedy piece? I mean, come on, since when has the Catholic church been concerned about the truth? They've spent years and years covering up child abuse, promoting those guilty of it and paying out over a billion dollars in settlements.
Truth? Beauty?? [/QB]
Somehow it didn't sound "with all due respect".
My god it is tough to be a Christian these days, much less a Catholic.
Apparently, you did not read my reply or the essay. There is a great deal of truth and beauty in the Christian Community, as there are in many other religious traditions.
While it is true that many of the Church’s Clergy have failed miserably, and have committed unpardonable sins and even crimes in their sometimes isolated arrogance; you can not tar the entire church as evil or corrupt. Considering the size of the Church, the abuses have actually been few and minor when compared with society as a whole, or even other religious organizations.
I do not excuse the crimes or abuse, or the institutional clergy’s role in covering it up. I state a fact. Studies of other religious and social organizations show the same or even higher levels of abuse (LCA 2002; State of New York AG 2001; State of MA AG 2000; UCSB 2001). It is our challenge AS A SOCIETY, as a COMMUNITTY, to ensure that things like that are never allowed to happen again.
The civilizing influence of the Church and the good it has done in so many areas sadly don’t seem to make good news bites or Ad copy.
In many parts of the world, the Church is still the only institution many people can turn to in hard times of trouble. The Church has a long history throughout the world of protecting the poor and disenfranchised from unscrupulous merchants, developers, politicians, landowning aristocracies, etc. The World would be a much poorer place without the 37% of the world’s total of free hospitals and clinics run by the Church (WHO – 1992). The world would be a much less enlightened, much darker place without the tens of thousands of Grade schools, Middle Schools, High schools, Colleges, and Universities that have led western civilization since long before any modern government was considered. Many of these exist despite the active persecution of rapacious governments and the wealthy.
While many people are justifiably upset at the current Administration of the US government for its huge failures at every level from the top down, almost nobody would advocate the overthrow of the US Government. I see no rush to the Mexican and Canadian borders of people intent on the dubious hope of finding a better home elsewhere. Rather we as citizens and members of the community call for change.
If 9/11 taught us as Americans anything, it is that you could burn down or firebomb every single federal building, including the White House and the Pentagon, and yet the United States of America will endure; because the US is not in those fragile buildings, documents, and even individuals. The US is the PEOPLE of this community; in the IDEALS we profess; the IDEAS that have made us great and strong.
So too the Catholic Church is not made up solely of the Clergy, even the Vatican Hierarchy - who are after all only as human as you or I, or the beautiful Cathedrals and quiet forest chapels. The CHURCH is the LAITY who as a community profess certain common beliefs first articulated by the words and actions of a simple TEACHER more than 2000 years ago.
Despite the sometimes ill advised actions of its leadership, a Clergy who have frequently been isolated from the common people and insulated from any unpleasantness (If it is easy as a President to be surrounded by thousands who tell you only good news, how much more isolated can a man be who millions revere and think of as God’s representative on Earth?); despite a Clergy who are sometimes unable to see the ‘beauty and truth’ themselves; The “Truth and Beauty” exist in the Catholic Christian Communitas of the Laity, the traditions and pageantry, and the hope that we can change the world into a better place.
The Clergy is made up of simple, and sometimes not so simple, men and women, No more, no less. As such they fall to all of the sins and excesses of all human beings everywhere. They are no better or worse. Even the Pope is but a man.
I do not expect many people to understand that communitas. Many in the Church itself do not think of it that way. Many of the Clergy do not understand it. Many who do think of it that way are AFRAID of it to the point of denial. It is a concept that was thousands of years ahead of it’s time, breathtaking and revolutionary.
The Church is FAR to IMPORTANT to be left solely to Clergy.
Whatever your religion or considered thoughts on the subject, I will not attack you for your belief for that was not ‘THE WAY” of ‘THE TEACHER”. Instead, I will only leave you with his example, and his word.
Shalom
Rob
[ September 27, 2005, 04:22 PM: Message edited by: ITJock ]