Charlie in the Trees
Apr 21 2003, 09:39 PM
I like Carson Palmer. This was one of the first years I can remember that the Heisman Trophy was awarded to the player I would've picked for the Heisman if I had a vote. He's a stud and he's got that QB look about him.
All signs point to him having a disastrous pro career.
Why? Because it looks like a done-deal that he's going to be drafted by the Cincinnati Bengals with the first pick in the NFL draft. He's going to be the new Akili Smith -- a great (and uncharacteristic) senior year leading to a skyrocketing of his draft value.
What if anything can be done to make Palmer a second round pick from some 7-9 team, which would allow him the chance at a decent NFL career? I mean, what are the odds of being a QB drafted in the first round by the Bengals and having a viable pro career? Higher or lower than the odds that Bengals and the Reds would lead their respective leagues in payroll?
sportinlife
Apr 22 2003, 12:37 AM
It's interesting to see what he thinks in his
USC bio under the sections "personal" and "Carson Plamer On".
He obviously feels he has other options in life. always a good thing for an athlete because their careers are so vulnerable to injury, either chronic or acute. Somehow I don't think he'll disappear no matter where he plays.
Adam
Apr 22 2003, 08:46 AM
I think choosing Palmer is a mistake both for the QB and the Bengals. It is extremely rare for a QB to be an impact player in his first year--even on a good team & Cincinnati doesn't qualify as a good team. I think the Bengals would have been smart to trade their first-round pick to try to get three/four seasoned position players. Even if they had to forgo Palmer, there would still be some good QBs available when the Bengals second-round pick comes along. Additionally, it will cost the Bengals approximately $50 million to sign Palmer and, if I am a fan, I wouldn't want to hear that we STILL wouldn't be a top tier team without other solid position players or that Palmer will be starting only four or five games as he's still learning the system.
~Adam
phillyrunner
Apr 22 2003, 05:58 PM
I agree the Bengals drafting Palmer probably would not be a good idea. They have many other holes to fill. It would be better for him to go to a better team than waste away with a bad team. Plus even if he is drafted by the Bengals there is no guarantee they could sign him. I would try to trade him for a couple of quality picks further down in the draft.
Joe in Philly
Apr 23 2003, 12:16 PM
It's mind-boggling that none of these teams that need a quarterback have contacted the Eagles regarding A.J. Feeley. Are they stupid? Weren't they watching last year?
The article I read in today's paper said barring a last-minute offer out of nowhere before the draft, he'll be back with the Eagles for one more year. After that he's a restricted free agent and likely will look to sign elsewhere where he'll get a chance to play.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.