Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Pat Tillman, US Army Ranger
Outsports Discussion Board > Outsports > Football, Pro
Pages: 1, 2
J T
This young man is a truly a hero in our minds, hearts, and eyes instead of some of our "selfish" sports stars that we have worshipped on a daily basis. I can't think of another dedicated person from the world of sports since Ted Williams's service to our country during WWII and the Korean War and Bob Kalsu's service during Vietnam.

Here is a quote from his former NFL coach, Dave McGinnis, that sums it up:

"He represented all that was good in sports ... passion, honor, integrity, and dignity."

My prayers go out to his family (i.e. wife, father, mother, and his brother).
HornFan
A True American Patriot. Thank you Pat. Rest in Peace.
Joe in Philly
QUOTE
poohnatl:
I wonder if every American would have Pat's bravery. Not the bravery to battle, we have courageous men and women right now fighting and dying for the USA, but the bravery to walk away from large sums of money, financial stability, some media fame, a nice house, nice cars; just walk away from all of the things you've dreamed of because you put the needs of others ahead of your own.
Clearly we're not all cut out for it. I recall there was a boxer--was it Riddick Bowe?--who joined the Army a while back and quit after like two days? That was a joke.
azairforce
We dont see the likes of Pat Tillman very often and he will be truly missed. He never wanted any special attention and I cant tell you how hard Ranger training is, its not a walk in the park at all. I have a few freinds in the Army that are Rangers, they are the best of the best in the Army.

The terrain in Afghanistan is very rough Tom, the mountian ranges are huge, and there are rocks everywhere, ive never seen so many damn rocks in all my life. We did work with a few of the Afghan troops, and I did get a chance to talk to some of them about the horrors of the Taliban and what some of the people suffered during that time.

Sport Best wishes to your nephew wish him the very best
alphamale
I had to write this to get it off my chest, I can't say it to anyone in person because i would be so chastised. I knew Pat Tillman, not as a friend, but as someone that was in many of his business classes and observed him on and off campus, and watched him play football as a Sun Devil and Cardinal. Unlike Jake Plummer that was his teammate, and was always very pleasant. I cannot say he was an angel or a saint as some paint him, he was quirky and even mean. I felt that his quirkeness was used to grab attention and I felt that he was so into the legend he was creating that he used opportunities to build on it. I just wished that someone would have told him that he didnt need to have to add war hero to his legend. If he had lived and returned, the opportunities for this guy would have been great, probably much better than if he had stayed in football and maybe had been cut from a roster or injured. I hate that this makes me sound mean, I am not trying to be mean, I am so truly sad. I even had a crush on him in college, and these sad days have brought me back to that time when I did see him on campus, or club rio or a marketing class. I just hate that maybe he joined to create more of a legend for himself and lost, but more sadly left his loved ones to deal with this sadness. Whatever his reasons, I do feel that he is a hero, and i'm sure he'll be missed by many, I have some memories that bring me to a more innocent time too, Thanks, Pat.
araanib
I know this is somewhat old news, but I just today have gotten around to articulating what I think about Tillman. It's not that he should be deified because he gave something up, took the road less travelled, and didn't come back. It's that he represents, I think, a much happier time. When a sports hero becomes a war dead, it alerts the rest of the sleeping public that we're no longer living the same life we were when Tillman was kicking ass for ASU.

And by the way, alphamale, it's very much ok to say that Tillman was occasionally mean and a little self-promotional. We all are, and that what makes his death so sad ... because it was just like everyone elses. No matter how rich, how smart, how accomplished, a bullet will rip out your organs just the same.
Joe in Philly
Tillman a \"Rambo-like idiot\"?? A UMass student wrote a column for the college paper; the title of the column: "Pat Tillman is not a hero: he got what was coming to him." This guy's just looking for trouble.
Justin Cognito
HATE. Just... HATE.

I heard the story this morning, and wanted to take a hatchet to the television set. I just have this... thing against people who have absolutely no respect for the dead.

Hey. ass****. What Pat Tillman did was stick himself in the line of duty with the intention of helping to protect America from outside threats. Tillman didn't choose to go to Iraq; he chose to serve in the military because of 9/11, and got sent to Iraq as an indirect result. You can say want you want to about the war in Iraq being Vietnam 2: Jingoistic Boogaloo; just leave the dead out of it.

[ April 29, 2004, 01:20 PM: Message edited by: Justin Cognito ]
DestinyRules
QUOTE
Denver Fan:
Pat Tillman gave up the NFL to fight for his country in Afganistan. He is a true hero, unlike those here who talk a big game but would never go do it themselves.
I'd be willing to fight a war that was JUSTIFIED, not this immoral piece of crap war fought for all the wrong reasons.

I'm so sick and bleeping tired of hearing about Pat Tillman the hero. He was one soldier who died in Afghanistan, like so many others who fought and died for our country before him. So he walked away from a professional football contract. Let's not set out to canonize him just yet.

My heart goes out to the families of all our armed forces. I may not agree with the reasons they're over there, but I feel the debt to all those who risk and give their lives for our freedoms. Even the ones who walk away from multi-million dollar contracts to do it.

Simeon Rice's comment was blatantly out of line.
Eric Swanson
A colleague of mine wrote what I thought was a very strong column about Tillman. If you're interested, look it up at www.dodgeglobe.com (it appeared in the April 24 edition, I think.)
twin58
QUOTE
TomFord
Do you know of any sites that are good for reading up on how our forces are faring in Afghanistan?
Bagram Air Base Afghanistan
azairforce
thanks for the website Twin
those are very recent pics too. I worked in the tower, thats no lie about the dust either its everywhere!! I've never seen so much damn dust in all my life. Thanks again for the website.

Tom Ford check out the pics, very much update pics and any info you want from me please dont hesitate to ask
twin58
QUOTE
azairforce
thanks for the website Twin
those are very recent pics too.
Because, as do all the listers at Outsports, you immediately download all my messages to your Mac and hyperlink them with Hypercard, you have no doubt noticed that I posted it in P&R a few months back.

http://66.241.240.127/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.c...t=001197#000020
bobby78751
How many people will have Ted Rall on a hit list after this editorial cartoon about Pat Tillman?
Pat Tillman editorial cartoon
Joe in Philly
QUOTE
RGMike:
the entire article is here:

Tillman Without Tears
From the article:

QUOTE
He was the same person who often talked late into the night with his linebackers coach at ASU, prying apart stereotypes about college football players and future soldiers.

"He talked about gays,'' Lyle Setencich, the former ASU assistant said. "He asked me, 'Could you coach gays?' " Setencich told Tillman yes. He could, and he had. He repeated that at the memorial service, televised on ESPN, in front of the sports world, showing another side of a coach, another side of an American hero.
Justin Cognito
QUOTE
How many people will have Ted Rall on a hit list after this editorial cartoon about Pat Tillman?
First his cartoon depicting 9/11 widows as greedy shrews. Then his cartoon depicting the FDNY in 2011 as fitlhy stinking rich. And now this.

Choke on my f**k, Rall.
fantomas
QUOTE
J T:
This young man is a truly a hero in our minds, hearts, and eyes instead of some of our "selfish" sports stars that we have worshipped on a daily basis. I can't think of another dedicated person from the world of sports since Ted Williams's service to our country during WWII and the Korean War and Bob Kalsu's service during Vietnam.
Actually, quite a few former athletes served the U.S.--not just Ted Williams, but Bob Feller, Stan Musial, etc.

I'm with you, Bill W, re: Pholly and a few others.... As I said to one recently (sorry, Godwin's Law broken), "Sieg heil."
thersis
when this sad story couldn't get any more tragic, it suddenly does. according to this source pat tilman was killed by friendly fire.
Joe in Philly
QUOTE
Initial reports by the Army had suggested that Tillman was killed by enemy gunfire when he led his team to help another group of ambushed soldiers.

"While there was no one specific finding of fault, the investigation results indicate that Cpl. Tillman probably died as a result of friendly fire while his unit was engaged in combat with enemy forces," Lt. Gen. Philip R. Kensinger Jr. said in a brief statement to reporters at the Army Special Operations Command.

Kensinger said the firefight took place in "very severe and constricted terrain with impaired light" with 10 to 12 enemy combatants firing on U.S. forces.

But an Afghan military official told The Associated Press on Saturday that Tillman died because of a "misunderstanding" when two mixed groups of American and Afghan soldiers began firing wildly in the confusion following a land mine explosion.

Speaking on condition of anonymity, the Afghan official said, "[There] were no enemy forces" present when Tillman died.
What a waste.
Jim Allen
From Ted Rall:
QUOTE
So much for the argument that Tillman died fighting for his country. Or for the bullshit cover story concocted by the military to justify awarding him a posthumous Silver Star. I wonder if the Pentagon will have the integrity to revoke it?

So, to recap: Tillman gave up $3.6 million to get killed by his fellow soldiers. I guess I do owe an apology after all, but not for calling him a sap: In my cartoon, I said Tillman got offed by the Afghan resistance. That part, as it turns out, wasn't true.

Bushie war apologists may email their apologies to MSNBC, which canceled my cartoons as the result of my cartoon. And prospective soldiers may want to take this opportunity to reconsider the wisdom of enlisting. It's bad enough to get killed by friendly fire; it's still worse to get killed by friendly fire while fighting an unjust, illegal and unjustifiable war.
Ted Rall 1, Justin Cognito nil.
smalltownboy
Great to hear the Tillman family speaking out on the propaganda our government fed to its masses...better to tell a lie and get the flags a waving (again) then to feed the truth, I suppose. rolleyes.gif
Pat Tillman's Family Speaks Out

NJ
millerbeach
Gosh, more lies from this administration? What a shock! This takes the sleaze level of this adminsitration to a new height. Keep it up, GWB! Pretty soon, the Clinton administration will look as pure as driven snow.
fenwayguy
The Washington Post interview referenced by CNN in NathanJones' post above.
QUOTE
"Every day is sort of emotional," Mary Tillman said. "It just keeps slapping me in the face. To find that he was killed in this debacle -- everything that could have gone wrong did -- it's so much harder to take. We should not have been subjected to all of this. This lie was to cover their image. I think there's a lot more yet that we don't even know, or they wouldn't still be covering their tails.

"If this is what happens when someone high profile dies, I can only imagine what happens with everyone else."
bobby78751
Geez, these liars just can't quit lying! I think this goes along with catapulting the propaganda.
Army Again Denies Cover-Up in Tillman Case
millerbeach
Now Bobby, how do you expect them to recruit more men for the death machine if they tell the truth?
sportinlife
Surprisingly the word "murder" hasn't surfaced in this event. I assume such a thing would be hard to define, and harder to prove even with an ethical administration in power in our government.

I suspect historians will inspect it as such only if it becomes a bigger controversy than it is, and has consequences for the Commander-in-Chief. For now it seems the political air smells so bad that even this stink doesn't smell.
bobby78751
QUOTE
sportinlife:
Surprisingly the word "murder" hasn't surfaced in this event.
Murder would involve intent. While the intent was to kill the "enemy", I don't think the specific intent was to kill Pat Tillman...which would result in murder. This could be classified as an accidental homicide. Ah, legalese. smile.gif Still, I'd like to see a punishment result from this tragedy.
sportinlife
QUOTE
bobby78751:
Murder would involve intent.
Only a credible investigation by an independent trustworthy authority could determine that. History may be the only one.

There are such things as jealousy, even among troops in the midst of battle. Tillman was a very highly publicized recruit. They all knew his history. Small-mindedness does not stop at the barracks door. Troops are human like us all.
sportinlife
There is a compelling reason that gay men should be interested in the reopening of the investigation into Pat Tillman's death. Tillman may have been known to be "not religious" in a war in which both sides have claimed support from God. Openly gay men would be assumed not to fit the conservative view of religion held by many if not most in the military. Could Tillman's agnosticism be deadly?
Joe in Philly
It's a major, major, extreme, even ridiculous stretch to think that he might have been gay and was murdered because he was gay, or because he was an agnostic, and not killed by "friendly fire" in some operation that was either poorly planned or conducted by poorly trained personnel or whatever, just because there's a new investigation into what happened.
sportinlife
Isn't this the third investigation? This is a criminal investigation. This is relatively rare.
A crime suggests a motive is suspected. We are not dealing with the most honest administration when it comes to investigating itself. Secrecy and deceit have become its hallmarks. Tillman does not have to have been gay to earn the ire of a fellow soldier. One thing revealed so far is that a squad leader shot first and others followed. I haven't seen or heard of the name of the squad leader. What if this were civilian?
fenwayguy
QUOTE
sportinlife:
A crime suggests a motive is suspected.
Presumably there's the military equivalent of criminal negligence, too -- maybe dereliction of duty on the part of the platoon leader?
canmark
AP article on ESPN.com: Pat Tillman's brother Kevin speaks out against war

QUOTE
Kevin Tillman, a former Army Ranger who served in Iraq and Afghanistan with his older brother, Pat Tillman, has remained silent since his brother's death in 2004. But this week, he wrote a scathing indictment of the war in Iraq, the Bush administration and American apathy.

"Somehow, the more soldiers that die, the more legitimate the illegal invasion becomes," Kevin wrote on Truthdig.com, which purchased his work.
* * *
"Somehow, the same incompetent, narcissistic, virtueless, vacuous, malicious criminals are still in charge of this country. Somehow, this is tolerated. Somehow, nobody is accountable for this."
sportinlife
This headline, a quote from the Tillman's mother, in this earlier Truthdig article pretty much sums it up:

‘They tried to attach themselves to his virtue; then they wiped their feet with him.’--Mary Tillman
UCLAfan
Sometimes a warrior's true fight is the one to halt combat. Kevin Tillman has my highest regard for seeing the light and getting the fighting to stop.

It sickens me to think that the Bush Regime and its lackeys are trying to use his brother's death to help justify continuing their political agenda. It's wrong, it's dangerous, and it's completely disgusting!
SCTrojan
QUOTE(canmark @ Oct 21 2006, 09:48 PM) *


Here's the full article. Scathing!
George Twins fan
Finally someone to be held accountable for Tillman's death and the subsequent coverup.

http://www.cnn.com/2007/US/03/23/tillman.death/index.html
fenwayguy
After a fifth Pentagon "investigation" into Tillman's death and the subsequent coverup, it's time for Congressional hearings.
QUOTE
"Perhaps subpoenas are necessary to elicit candor and accuracy from the military," (Tillman's relatives) said.
UCLAfan
It's about time Congress got involved!
UCLAfan
Pat Tillman's brother, Kevin, a former Army Ranger himself, railed against the Army and how they handled Pat's death. Yes, it truly was sickening to know that the military out and out lied through their teeth.

Then, former PFC Jessica Lynch also spoke out against the media-whoring that the military engaged in. She proclaimed that she was never the media darling that the military made her out to be.

Yes, why is there this culture of lying and making up stories in the military?
fantomas
The military wants to portray itself as virtuous, because really, in a war scenario, what are its members doing? Killing people. So it makes sense to me that the military would lie and try to create false heroes, especially a military under the command of the worst and most untruthful president we have ever had.

But my question is, what are we going to do about our "mainstream" "liberal" media, who actively colluded with the Bush administration in these lies about Tillman and Lynch, who have failed to take any responsibility for their actions, and who continue to protect Bush--except when forced by bloggers, the new Democratic Congress, or whistleblowers--and champion him at every stage? Just think of how Judith Miller of the New York Times actively and repeatedly wrote administration lies to gin up support for the Iraq War, or how mainstream "liberal" journalists like Tim Russert and Matt Cooper were active participants in the scheme to smear Ambassador Joseph Wilson IV and out his wife, undercover agent Valerie Plame. Or think about how the mainstream media actively attacked and misrepresented Vice President Gore in 1999 and 2000, then sat on their hands as Bush was appointed in 2000, as the post-9/11 pseudo-investigations occurred, as the Swift Boat liars smeared Kerry in 2004, as Bush has hovered at around 32-36% popularity and Americans have finally said they've had enough. The "mainstream" "liberal" media are STILL failing to report how the majority of Americans have had enough of Bush's Iraqmire, and support either an immediate or a phased withdrawal. Most Americans agree with Democratic Majority Leader Harry Reid, and not with the Dick. Yet CNN uses terms like "defeatist" Dems, and lets Bush attack the will of the American people without criticism. It's disgusting.

Unless we do something about our lackey, corporatist media, we are going to continue to be lied to again and again. They refuse to put together all the pieces concerning this administration, which has damaged our nation incalculably. We'll be looking back two years from now and asking ourselves, how on earth did it all happen, and one central explanation we shouldn't ever forget is: our "mainstream" "liberal" media worked overtime to make the Bush nightmare possible.
sportinlife
This whole affair makes me so angry it's difficult to see straight sometimes, much less think straight. It is good that Pat Tillman, and his brother, and especially his mother Mary, have all put faces on the casualties in this war and the families associated with them.

But I wish every American could check the DoD Confirmation List once a day, just to remind themselves that these are all people with names, families and histories. And perhaps to think about the pain so many are going through.

It should be a non-partisan act to just take a few seconds every day to see the actual new names of individuals added.
fantomas
QUOTE(sportinlife @ Apr 26 2007, 01:35 AM) *


But I wish every American could check the DoD Confirmation List once a day, just to remind themselves that these are all people with names, families and histories. And perhaps to think about the pain so many are going through.


Yes, we should check that list, and we should take time out to remember the more than 3300 US soldiers and sailors who've been killed in this war, and the many thousands of our servicepeople who've been wounded and injured. No, they weren't all famous and handsome and rich like Pat Tillman, but they deserve our thanks and our tribute.

We had a national week of mourning over the horrific slaughter down at Virginia Tech, but in this same month, we've had one of the highest death tolls of our troops in the entire war. Also, last year alone, over 35,000 Iraqis were killed. The vast majority were innocent people or soldiers or police who were working with us.

So why don't we devote time on a regular basis to remember the fallen troops, who as you say, were our fellow Americans, who gave their lives on our behalf and for a terrible series of lies and deceptions, and also to the Iraqi people, especially because of the horrific situation that the US has unleashed upon them?
GymMountainEER
Videos of testimony-


Kevin Tillman speaks out


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUCyr3B3IlM...ted&search=


West Virginia's Jessica Lynch's speaks out against the propoganda machine:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l0OyihqYfF4
theodoresdaddy
I'm so proud of her-she could have easily gone along with the lies but she didn't
Elemental
QUOTE(fantomas @ Apr 26 2007, 03:40 AM) *

Yes, we should check that list, and we should take time out to remember the more than 3300 US soldiers and sailors who've been killed in this war, and the many thousands of our servicepeople who've been wounded and injured. No, they weren't all famous and handsome and rich like Pat Tillman, but they deserve our thanks and our tribute.

We had a national week of mourning over the horrific slaughter down at Virginia Tech, but in this same month, we've had one of the highest death tolls of our troops in the entire war. Also, last year alone, over 35,000 Iraqis were killed. The vast majority were innocent people or soldiers or police who were working with us.

So why don't we devote time on a regular basis to remember the fallen troops, who as you say, were our fellow Americans, who gave their lives on our behalf and for a terrible series of lies and deceptions, and also to the Iraqi people, especially because of the horrific situation that the US has unleashed upon them?

Well put as always, fantomas. SHALOM TO THE TROOPS AND TO THE IRAQI PEOPLE.
canmark
A documentary about Pat Tillman will be shown at the Sundance Film Festival, The Tillman Story.
QUOTE
Pat Tillman gave up his professional football career to join the Army Rangers in 2002—and became an instant symbol of patriotic fervor and unflinching duty. But the truth about Pat Tillman is far more complex, and ultimately more heroic, than the caricature created by the media. And when the government tried to turn his death into war propaganda, they took on the wrong family. From her home in the Santa Cruz mountains, Pat’s mother, Dannie Tillman, led the family’s crusade to reveal the truth beneath the mythology of their son’s life and death.

Featuring candid and revelatory interviews with Pat's fellow soldiers as well as his family, Amir Bar-Lev’s emotional and insightful film not only shines a light on the shady aftermath of Pat’s death and calls to task the entire chain of command but also examines themes as timeless as the notion of heroism itself.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.