OK, this will be long. Bear with me, if you please.

(Will I need a soapbox?) :confused:
I posted in the
Christopher Reeve, RIP thread about
a cartoon related to Ken Caminiti's passing, which I found to be "simultaneously funny, sad, tasteless, ignorant, unfair, low, cheap, uncompassionate, and true."
QUOTE
satxbuddy1:
For whatever biological reason, Cammy couldn't shake his addicitions...
Some years ago, I learned something in one of my classes that I will never forget.
This one day, while our professor was explaining to us the difficult concepts required to have at least a grasp of the subjects concerning the course, one of the students started laughing uncontrollably. It was evident that he was trying to control himself, but, as much as he tried, he just couldn't stop. After a few minutes, the professor, very calmly, asked him if there was something wrong or if he had anything to comment on what she was saying. He said no and, apparently because of her asking, stopped laughing.
About ten minutes later, the guy started laughing again. I was in the back corner of the very small classroom, and took a look at the other students' faces, who were like, "What is with this guy?" I guess we all felt embarrassed for, and somewhat angry at, him for his actions, considering the subject of the course was a very serious one and the professor was a world-renowned intellectual and writer. The guy did manage to control himself, but a few minutes later, started again! The professor kindly asked him that if the subject was funny to him that he then should leave until he could control his laughter. He didn't return in the forty minutes left.
At the end of the class, our professor asked us if any of us knew him (as a friend or acquaintance). The ones who responded said no and started complaining about his behavior. Our professor told us: "If any of you happen to talk to him and if, by chance, he asks for help, please do so. None of us know if he's dealing with some problem in his life, maybe an illness of some kind. I am aware that he is a very bright person, so I ask you for some understanding." We were all left speechless. All those complaints and accusations --"How dare he!," "What was he thinking?!," etc.-- turned to "Oh, yes, definitely," and our facial expressions went from scowling to feeling humbled, ashamed...for ourselves.
Here was this woman, whom we thought had all the right in the world to feel offended by what we deemed was "that guy"'s disrespectfulness and lack of decorum, giving us a lesson in wisdom, humbleness, and a deep understanding of humanity.
I learned some time later that he apparently was suffering from some mental illness.
My favorite pop singer said once in an interview that it was funny to her how we all seem to live together in the world, in the same space, and that that somehow makes us think we all lead more or less the same lives, when in reality we don't; that we pass one another by in the streets and yet are completely unaware of each other's inner lives.
I would add to that that even oneself doesn't know, and will never know, completely --only partially-- why one acts this or that way. There are so many reasons --psychological, biological, etc.--, as satxbuddy1 wrote, that could provide answers to the mystery of the causes of our decisions and actions. If Caminiti did wrong or right was only for him to say. None of us knew really what his life was like, and I believe it would be naïve to act as if we could never be in the same position as he was, as if we already knew what's in store for us. "Failure," or what is considered as such in society, could be one step away from us at any moment. One can work as hard as possible to try and not end up oneself in such situations, but it's all contingent. As Smokey Robinson wrote in "The Hunter Gets Captured by the Game"
Everyday things change
And the world puts on a new face
Certain things rearrange
And the world seems like a new placeand Joni Mitchell in "Amelia"
People will tell you where they've gone
They'll tell you where to go
But till you get there yourself
You never really know
Where some have found their paradise
Others just come to harmWho am I to think or say that his life was or was not a waste? Am I immune to failure? Why do I define a person's life by only the two or three aspects that are publicly known about him? Is it possible for me to do away with commonplace judgements as these? Maybe, maybe not...
I'd like to share with you the lyrics to another Joni Mitchell song. Since first hearing it, I had never found a moment where I could relate it to me or my life, but I think the time has come.
Borderline
Everybody looks so ill at ease
So distrustful so displeased
Running down the table
I see a borderline
Like a barbed wire fence
Strung tight, strung tense
Prickling with pretense
A borderline
Why are you smirking at your friend?
Is this to be the night when
All well-wishing ends?
All credibility revoked?
Thin skin, thick jokes!
Can we blame it on the smoke
This borderline?
Every bristling shaft of pride
Church or nation
Team or tribe
Every notion we subscribe to
Is just a borderline
Good or bad, we think we know
As if thinking makes things so!
All convictions grow along a borderline
Smug in your jaded expertise
You scathe the wonder world
And you praise barbarity
In this illusionary place--
This scared hard-edged rat race
All liberty is laced with
Borderlines
Every income, every age
Every fashion-plated rage
Every measure, every gauge
Creates a borderline
Every stone thrown through glass
Every mean-streets kick-ass
Every swan caught on the grass
Will draw a borderline
You snipe so steady
You snub so snide--
So ripe and ready
To diminish and deride!
You're so quick to condescend
My opinionated friend
All you deface, all you defend
Is just a borderline
Just a borderline ...
Another borderline ...
Just a borderline [ October 13, 2004, 04:09 AM: Message edited by: noumenon ]