QUOTE(mdterp01 @ Oct 10 2009, 02:30 PM)

Rout is correct....6-1, 6-3. Nadal has been on the receiving end of a few of these beatdowns this year. Even when Federer was going through his downs, no one ever beat him with that kind of scoreline. Congrats to Cilic.
So ... the French Open Final of 2008 where Federer won but four measly games, had his serve broken six times and lost 6-1 6-3 6-0 is something you don't consider a "beatdown"?

. I mean ..how embarrassing!! Pete Sampras
never got "bageled" in the Final of a Major
I mean..terp honey..we all know you hate Nadal and we all know you would eat Federer's poo-poo at the drop of a hat. But the spurious, nonsensical, non-factual claims you routinely make here are clearly driven but how much you can't stand the guy. Hate Nadal all you like - but get the facts right sweetheart; it just makes you look so pitifully unlearned when you don't. Federer did have almost as humiliating a result: the 2008 Indian Wells Semi-Final loss to Mardy Fish, 36 26. He managed one more game than Nadal did to Cilic. But Cilic is ranked #15; Fish at the time was ranked #98 (so he either had to play Qualifying or wait until at least two guys pulled out to get in the draw), and was 0-5 against Federer going into that one. So this one also qualifies as a "beatdown". Besides, Federer's choking usually starts happening in the 5th Set of a Major - like a
pair of 6-2 5th Set "beatdowns" while gasping for air this year alone.
Congrats are most deserved to Cilic. Although at this juncture of the year, it's not unusual to see the guys who've been winning bunches of the bigger titles and/or showing up at the business end of the biggest events earlier in the year give way to fresher guys who weren't as accomplished at the biggest events. Nadal managed to get to the Semis. Del Potro and Roddick just lost their
opening matches to guys ranked FAR below them (JMDP lost to a Qualifier). But is it surprising? Andy & JMDP have put together banner years in 2009; Nadal owned the first five months of the ATP Tour. At this stage of the season they're ripe to be taken out by guys who haven't played as deeply into anywhere near as many tournaments as they have. Federer's summer had been so momentous that he didn't want to risk tarnishing it by losing in any of these fall events - which he's been clearly prone to do in the past. So his "back trouble" sent him on hiatus. Same for Murray's "wrist". But somehow I think Federer's "back" and Murray's "wrist" will be just fine come London.
And does anyone remember what Donut Dave Nalbandian did to Federer, Nadal and Djokovic in the fall of 2007? He crushed all of them - twice in the case of Federer and Nadal that year sweeping both Madrid & Paris. And what became of Donut Dave after such stellar results? Well, a lot more of what we see all the time from him: losing to the other guys he'd just pounded, through most of 2008 and beyond. Cilic is one of the many ATP "also rans" who fully understand the top guys are likely to be either below par, off the radar or out for target practice after piling up their impressive results up to now. Let's see if Cilic will be able to pull off any amazing feats he achieves during this period again, on an occasion when the real money is down.
Nadal, Del Potro, Federer, Murray and Djokovic have already qualified for the only tournament left on the calendar that really counts: the Year End Championships in London. You could make the case that Djokovic needs to do well in these preliminary events going into the YEC because not only has he had substandard results in the Majors this year for a World #3, but he's also the current YEC titleholder. And he also needs some born fruit ASAP out of his new coaching arrangement with Todd Martin to justify Martin's salary. Federer, Nadal, and JMDP have Majors in the bag for 2009; Murray and Nadal lead the tour in titles won in 2009, each of them racking up five. History shows us that the best show up when the prizes are the biggest. And so it will be again. These five guys, plus the remaining three warm-bodies who qualify will put their best feet down when it counts most. Just like they always do.