QUOTE(NJ Jock @ Nov 16 2009, 12:29 PM)

I'm really on the fence about Belichick's coaching in the 4th quarter yesterday.
On the one hand, Kudos to Belichick for going for it on 4th and 2. He's trying to win the game and not just playing it safe by punting it away. To defend Belichick, I'd ask the following question: If you punt it at that point, what are the odds Peyton Manning drives the length of the field to score the winning TD? (rememeber there were still 2 minutes left on the clock and the Colts had a timeout) I don't know the stats, but I'd guess Manning has gotten it done the vast majority of the time in that situation.
I'll answer that with another question. Do you go for it and fail giving Manning a 30 yard field to work with, or punt it away and give him 70 yards to work with? Let's not forget, Manning struggled throughout the game throwing a couple of bad picks. He was no superstar for the vast majority of the game in the face of the Patriot defense.
A stunning decision for Belichick. And a slap in the face to his defense that had done the job well enough to that point.