QUOTE
JC:
Hey, Charlie, I got a question: weren't you the guy who thought Navratilova should be booed wherever she goes for her supposed anti-American (more anti-Bush, really) statements?
Yup. And I still think that. And I think celebs are a fair target, too. And, guess what? I don't have a problem if people don't want to let it go with regard to Rocker. If Rocker pitches in St. Pete, go ahead and have at it. Boo away.
What I don't agree with is this pattern: people who righteously claim that it is wrong to criticize the Dixie Chicks or Janeane Garofalo, making a big deal of the fact that they have a "first amendment right" to shoot their mouths off, yet somehow thinking that Rocker must be
institutionally punished for his idiocy. Al Gore, to exhume one name, said it was a "dark day for democracy" for people to criticize the Dixie Chicks. The Dixie Chicks and Janeane Garofalo do have a first amendment right to speak their minds. News flash: so does Rocker. And everyone's got a first amendment right to criticize all of the above for whatever they may say.
But I do think it is hypocrisy to claim, on the one hand, that by defending the Dixie Chicks right to spew forth (and, truth be told, I'm more offended by their boring music than their anti-Bush politics), you are simply defending the right to free speech, but on the other hand, to attack Rocker for speaking his peace to the news media. From my perspective, the people who are the most hardcore about attacking Rocker for speaking his (small) mind are also disproportionally the ones who are righteously indignant that we need to separate politics from art in patronizing the works of their favorite left wing celebrities.
Pick one horse and ride it, please.
Back to Rocker:
I hope Rocker gets his act together. I believe in forgiveness and redemption. I hope Janeane Garofalo and Susan Sarandon gets their acts together too. The D-Rays are severe punishment. Just like if Ms. Sarandon or Sean Penn were to be reduced to a sitcom on the WB. If Rocker or Navatilova were to genuinely repent their stupid comments, I would be very very happy.
[ April 11, 2003, 06:50 PM: Message edited by: Charlie in the Trees ]