From the NY Blade July 9, 2002 Dish Page, more on gay athletes.
"Boys of summer"
In the wake of the clamor over New York Met Mike Piazza's orientation, The Globe claims there are at least a half dozen major-league baseballers who are gay.
"I know of at least six major league ball players who are gay," a "leading commentator on homosexual culture" told the paper. "Fans, as well as their teammates,
would be stunned because these guys are good-looking, macho-type athletes."
Well, no wonder they’re good-looking; they’re gay, after all.
"Two play on the West Coast, and two more play in New York," the source continues. "Believe me, they are not alone. There are gay men hiding all over
baseball."
The paper says that rumors about the sexual orientation of New York's Yankee Derek Jeter and Met Roberto Alomar, and Baltimore Oriole Brady Anderson, have
been circulating for some time.
"There are so many rumors about [Anderson]," Dave Pallone, a former umpire who later came out of the closet, told the paper.